From left to right:
Falsifeye Mascara Brush
YSL Baby Doll Mascara Brush
L'Oréal Falselash Flutter (Butterfly) Mascara Brush
Let's start with the packaging. Packaging definitely isn't everything and although I probably will be drawn in by a sleek, stylish looking product, for me in general it's not nearly as important as e.g. the scent of a product. Having said that though, if there's something about the packaging that effects the practicality or use of it, that will be a minus point in my book and that's exactly the case with this mascara. The packaging is quite chunky and because it's rectangular as well, it takes up a lot of space in your makeup bag or in your makeup storage, and more importantly - and this probably sounds like a silly detail, but the handle of the wand doesn't sit very comfortably in your hand since it's angular and pointy.
Most mascaras don't really come into their own until after you've used them for a good few weeks, but after almost three weeks of use, the formula of Falsifeye is still quite wet and in order to volumise the lashes, you have to work at it for quite a while, but this could also at least be partly because of the brush. The brush is very VERY thick, and personally I think it's too thick. In theory a really thick brush should give great lash coverage, but when it's too thick like this one and the wand is also very stiff, it's difficult to get to all the lashes from the tiniest ones at the inner corner of your eye, to the outer ones. In short the coverage isn't great and when you go back in to cover the inner corner lashes, you have to be very careful not to smudge all over, since the angle is a bit tricky and there is zero flexibility of the wand. With a brush of this width I think it could benefit from having some kind of flex function, to make it easier to work with. On the other hand, it's probably this stiffness that helps to easily extend the lashes and create a wonderful fanning effect that really opens up the eye, and is flattering on everyone.
Even though the mascara isn't water- or smudge proof, it still lasts really well throughout the day and it's very easy to remove without any pulling on the lashes. To sum it up, the mascara does lengthen the lashes and the fanning effect is lovely, however for a volumised effect you really need to put in some effort. Overall it's an OK mascara and it's an ambitious attempt at a product that does it all - lengthen, volumise and fan, but for me it does fall short especially when you look at competing products in the same price range from Maybelline and Max Factor.
Loved the honest review dear ! So far for me Victoria Secret triple drama mascara was able to fulfil all the 3 claims.
ReplyDeletexoxo
Shreya
Hey Shreya, I didn't even know that VS did makeup :o). I'll keep that mind next time I see a VS shop :o). Xx
Deletegreat review dear I Love the packaging. New post on my blog =) Valentines outfit ideas =) hope you'll check it we can follow each other too if you like =) hugs http://anotsosecretlife2011.blogspot.com/
ReplyDeleteThank you very much, follow you now :o). Xx
DeleteI've been eyeing up this mascara and the Seventeen Doll eyes one but after reading this I think i'll steer clear of this one! Thanks for the honest review :) x
ReplyDeleteMolly's Beauty Spot | A Beauty & Lifestyle Blog
With a few tweeks of formula and brush it might be a very goo mascara, but at the moment it's not something I would repurchase :o). Xx
DeleteGreat review Charlotte xx
ReplyDeleteThat's so lovely - thank you very much :o). Xx
DeleteI've only ever used one Seventeen Mascara and I really liked it, I find that most mascaras come into their own once they dry out a little. Lovely honest review x
ReplyDeletefabheadtotoe.blogspot.co.uk
For me the mascara is almost perfect just before they run out LOL Xx
DeleteGreat post, thanks for the honest review :)
ReplyDeletelipstickandlightening.blogspot.com
Thank you very much :o) Xx
DeleteGood honest review...a shame that it didn't work out for you. At the moment I'm really loving L'oreal Telescopic in Carbon Black. I've really had good results from it and it is now a staple in my beauty bag.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing
Keisha xo
www.chrysalisgals.blogspot.com
Telescopic is another great formula, and definitely a mascara I would buy again :o). Xx
DeleteThanks so much for visiting me, I just followed you on BLOGLOVIN :) Would love if you followed back!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.fashionhypnotised.com/
Thank you very much - follow you now :o).
Deletegreat review and i love how u compared!
ReplyDeleteAh, that's so nice - thank you :o)! Xx
Deletegreat view of the tips, really shows how the brush can make a difference!
ReplyDeleteyou could take a look at my blog! just started!!! eekkk
https://www.bloglovin.com/butterflybeautydiaries
http://butterflybeautydiaries.blogspot.co.uk/
Thank you very much, definitely and the biggest isn't always the best :o). Xx
DeleteGreat review dear!! :) Lovely blog you have!
ReplyDeleteWould you like to follow each other? Let me know :)
Have a good week!!
Thanks a million, that's so nice of you - follow you now. Xx
Deletegreat review!!
ReplyDeletexx
bianca
www.worryaboutitlater.com
Thanks for the review! I am a huge packaging person, and I really didn't like how this product looked. Had no idea Seventeen made makeup either. What do you think of the YSL Baby Doll Mascara? It's one of my personal favorites. The brush is pretty thin and so is the formula, but it works well with my lashes.
ReplyDeleteMay from La Vie En May
Baby Doll is one of my favorites as well, I've almost used up the one I've got but I'll repurchase it straight away - it's beautiful and the brown shade is a lovely option to black :o). Xx
Deletegreat review!!!
ReplyDeletewww.thestylebender.com
Thank you very much :o). Xx
DeleteI really loved the comparison picture compared to other mascara wands. It really does show you just how much thicker the brush is. I have small eyes as it is, I'd be terrified of poking my eye out or something! Think I'll give this a miss and stick to my Max Factor Masterpiece MAX mascara for now. Love the honest and in-depth review!
ReplyDeleteKerry x
dulltoglam.blogspot.co.uk
Thank you so much, that's really nice of you and I always try to give an honest but balanced view of a product :o). Xx
DeleteI've never even glanced at Seventeen's display before and I didn't know they did anything other than nail polishes. I have such short and problematic lashes than lengthening and separation is so important. This Falsifeye brush does look slightly tricky to navigate.
ReplyDeleteI've just started using the L'Oreal Butterfly effect mascara and I love it!
Sej || What Would Grace Kelly Say?
x
I agree with you - the Butterfly is absolutely amazing and for me it does everything that I need - volume, length and flare, what else could a girl want :o). Xx
DeleteI think I have this mascara lying around somewhere, the fact that I don't know probably means that I wasn't very impressed either!xx
ReplyDeletewww.loobydoobahhdiidoo.blogspot.co.uk
LOL - a further few weeks into using it, I've decided it's definitely not for me since the formula has dried and is really cloggy ... Xx
Delete